who was your favourite Creepypasta?

d3m0nfr13nd 10/25/2021 09:26 pm 898

Anybody who had a creepypasta phase who was your favourite or if you cant pick just one ( i know i cant) who were your top 5 favourites)


Laughing JackJeff the KillerTicci Toby Smile DogBen Drowned

19 Replies

Sorry, you are unable to reply. If the thread is still open, you might have been blocked from commenting due to spam or abuse, or we might not have been able to verify that you are a real account. Try updating your profile and interacting more on the site. There are greater restrictions on forum comments due to spam. Spam comments will still not be published, even for verified accounts
Please log in to comment
Displaying 11-19 of 19 comments
Sort by:
Oct 26, 2021 8:00 am

1) eyeless jack

2) nathan the nobody

3) ticci toby

4) jeff the killer

5) bob (the guy that doesnt have arms)

Oct 26, 2021 6:33 am

ben drowned, ticci toby, and eyeless jack

Oct 26, 2021 5:59 am

i like jeff the killer, ben drowned, and ticci toby

Oct 26, 2021 5:35 am

i like x-virus man, idk if any other people know who he is but just his design <3

Oct 26, 2021 5:27 am

slenderman and ben drowned

Oct 26, 2021 4:56 am

CLOCKWORKKKK

Oct 26, 2021 4:27 am

i liked laughing jack and ticci toby

Oct 26, 2021 3:26 am

been in that phase for 5 years babeyyy rainbowsmile

n e wayzz IM DOING TOP 10 BECAUSE YEAH

1. jeff the killer

2. ben drowned (my twin)

3. x virus (hes so hot mmm baseball bat go brr)

4. ticci toby (even tho his creator doesnt want him apart of creepypasta anymore *sobbing*)

5. clockwork

6. dr. smiley

7. wilson the basher (his character design is just so mmmmm)

8. homicidal liu

9. eyeless jack

10. zero

hoodie isnt a creepypasta btw crying hes from a web series on youtube called marble hornets which is kinda similar to creepypasta in the sense that theres a being in it similar to slenderman called the operator, its rly awesome i def recommend it rainbowsmilebeating heart

Oct 26, 2021 1:58 am

i hyperfixated on ticci toby and JTK for a long time back in middle school. theyre my favorite ones to this day but i never really read or delve too deeply to creepypastas anymore since they creep me out

which is honestly hilarious seeing as how they didn't creep me out as much as they do now as compared to middle school.