25 Replies

Michaels with a coupon, Amazon especially if you have Prime, Joann's with a coupon, Target has some right now but may or may not keep carrying them, Bead Tin is awesome, Aliexpress is great for charms and novelty beads if you don't mind the wait, Dollar Tree has inexpensive assortments but they run smaller than a lot of places and don't always have them in stock. Some towns have bead specialty stores that may or may not have pony beads but will have weird stuff to add on.

avoid target because every time they had pony beads, it was super overpriced

beadtin is honestly your best bet, especially if you order in bulk. (consistent colors, huge selection, cheaper prices than even amazon, most beads made in the united states, etc.)