Sep 17th: A service I signed up for broke features on the site. I'm working on disabling it, so things should get back to normal soon. -Crumpet


JasperOfJupiter 9/15/2021 09:00 am 37

okkokok so big mac is so so obviously trans heres why (warning: gender dysphoria, mention of death)

some backround on big mac: he is a stalllion, quite big and burly, and has an extremely deep voice, and is part of the apple family (a big brother to apple jack and apple bloom, and a grandson to granny smith)

in "do princesses dream of magic sheep," when they're all in a dream and can do whatever they want, big mac choses to be a princess, and look feminine!

then, in "brotherhooves social," he has to pretend to be a mare for apple bloom to participate. and he finally talks! he only feels comfortable talking when he's "pretending" to be a woman. that is very easy to trace back to voice dysphoria

his voice dysphoria is also hinted at in the episode "where the apple lies". in this episode, we see big mac as a child, before his voice has gotten as deep as it is in the present. he has no dysphoria in this episode, even talking more than the average pony. some may argue that he stopped talking when his parents died. however, in this episode, he and applejack are already in granny smiths care, so that theory is driven to the ground, leaving voice dysphoria as the most logical explanation

if you actually read that thanks have some ice cream pinkicecream2

5 Replies

Please log in to comment
Displaying 1-5 of 5 comments
Sort by:
Sep 15, 2021 9:32 am
@tiasafalin: love this i bet rarity is always like are you sure you dont want to go with something.. else? maybe something that will highlight your coat?
Sep 15, 2021 9:31 am

@w0lfy_kAnd1: omg yess and when i rewatched it, i was also learning new flags, so i just kept seeing more!!

Sep 15, 2021 9:31 am

rainbow dashs hair is actually blue but they want to be cool so rarity helps him dye it (yes i hc rainbow dash as using they/he)

Sep 15, 2021 9:21 am

twilight sparkle is literally a walking bi flag therefore she bi (i think-)

Sep 15, 2021 9:06 am

One of my theories is that the colors of the ponies represent what sexuality is. (Example)

Also your theory is my new favorite thing, congratulations /pos hkheart